Georgian A.
1/5
July 2024
We arranged for McGimpsey Removals to deliver an antique wardrobe and bookcase from our antique warehouse in Scotland to an existing client in Northern Ireland, who had been happy with her previous purchases of antiques from us. Both items were fully traditionally restored and sold online from multiple professional photographs on our website and were in excellent condition for antiques that are over 100 years old. On collection their driver asked a secretary in an office (rather than our porter staff who carried out the two items, or myself) to sign a collection document that had ticks in boxes indicating damage (marks, scratches and chips) to both items. I was actually present when they were loaded and both were in excellent condition, as described on our web-page.
On delivery, a 20cm piece of the cornice was broken off and lying inside the wardrobe, a foot was badly damaged and multiple deep gouges, scratches and French polish damage were present on the doors, cornice, and sides. The doors were closed with adhesive tape directly on the French polish! The client quite rightly would not accept the badly damaged wardrobe.
The McGimpsey staff told our customer that they could not find the shelves of the bookcase and so she refused to accept it also. McGimpsey staff later contacted her to say they had found them - they were present in the bookcase all along. However, she was upset by the damage to the wardrobe and the poor transport service that she refused to accept the bookcase also.
McGimpsey Removals stated that these extensive damages were present when they uplifted them from our warehouse – although they have a separate damage category for broken (BR) and dented (D) which the wardrobe was – that had not been ticked on collection. Having extensively damaged our wardrobe, we had to pay them for transport of the wardrobe to Northern Ireland (£564) and then we had to pay (£468) for cabinetmaking repairs and French polishing to repair the wardrobe, that was devalued by the repaired damage.
To think that we would send a broken, gouged, and scratched wardrobe overseas knowing that under the sales of good act and we being members of the main antique trade body LAPADA (London and Provincial Antique Dealers Association) that a refund would be immediately due is beyond belief.
It is interesting that the collection document also indicated that the bookcase was damaged on collection (marks, scratches, and chips)–However, it was perfect when it left us and when they delivered it back.
Do not sign any documents this firm asks you to on collection, because if they damage your goods – they will have a document showing that the goods were already damaged on collection. This is a totally untrustworthy transport firm and the worst transporters we have used in 45 years of business.
We raised an action against them in the small claims court in Edinburgh Sheriff Court for our losses.
Unfortunately, McGimpsey's terms and conditions only allow claims to be made against them in Northern Ireland and so at a hearing on 24th April 2025 Sheriff Gill of the Small Claims Court in Edinburgh could not proceed with the case.
It is interesting that another of their terms and conditions is that their maximum payment for any damage is £40.00 and so it will not be worthwhile raising an action in Northern Ireland.
The repairs and transport of our damaged wardrobe were £1032.00 as well as loss of a £2770 sale to an existing customer who we have now lost and also, damage to our reputation.
The first photograph is of the wardrobe as it left our warehouse. The remaining photographs are of the wardrobe following delivery by McGimpsey Brothers Removals.